Mother Carmel’s enigmatic journey in Elbaf has captivated fans for years. Her prolonged stay raises numerous questions about her experiences and the mysteries surrounding her time in the “House of Sheep.” As we delve into this intriguing narrative, we will explore the implications of her 37-year absence and the warnings from explorer Louis Arnaud. Join us as we uncover the secrets of Elbaf and the fate of Mother Carmel.

The Mystery of Mother Carmel’s Long Stay in Elbaf

For 37 years, Mother Carmel resided in a facility known as the “House of Sheep” in Elbaf. This extended stay raises questions about what might have transpired during her time there. Did something significant happen to her, or was her experience in Elbaf just a normal part of her life?

Advice from Louis Arnaud

InONE PIECE Chapter 1132, explorer Louis Arnaud warns adventurers about the mysterious land of Elbaf, stating, “Do not linger in this land.” He adds, “Do not regret the time lost that cannot be returned.” These words carry a deep meaning, especially for the Straw Hat crew, Bonney, and Lilith (Dr. Vegapunk), who are likely to stay longer than they should. It seems improbable that they will leave without encountering some form of trouble.

The exact duration that constitutes “lingering” remains unclear, but it is reasonable to assume that the Straw Hats will not be in Elbaf for an extended period, perhaps not exceeding a year. However, considering the upcoming “Winter Solstice Festival,” which involves a 12-day fasting tradition, their stay could last at least two weeks. This festival, symbolizing the “death and resurrection of the sun,” may play a crucial role in the narrative.

Mother Carmel’s Time in Elbaf

Many fans have speculated about the implications of Arnaud’s warning. Could it be that those who stay too long in Elbaf face dire consequences? However, there is little evidence to suggest that Mother Carmel experienced any significant changes during her 37 years in Elbaf. She left the island due to the chaos caused by Big Mom, but what happened afterward? There may still be secrets hidden within her story, but physically, she showed no signs of aging or transformation.

Interactions with external parties, such as CP0, appeared to remain consistent throughout her stay. It seems that time flowed differently for her compared to the outside world, as she did not age significantly during her time in Elbaf. This raises questions about the nature of time in Elbaf and whether it affects humans differently than giants.

Reasons Not to Linger

Observing Mother Carmel and the children from the “House of Sheep,” it seems that a prolonged stay does not necessarily lead to physical changes in humans. Big Mom’s personality was innate, and it is unlikely that her time in Elbaf directly caused the “Mother Carmel Disappearance Incident.” Arnaud’s warning remains enigmatic, and its true meaning is still up for debate.

Could it be that the flow of time in Elbaf differs from other lands? While this theory has been suggested, there is currently no concrete evidence to support it. After all, everyone, including Big Mom, moved on to other islands without any noticeable changes. The implications of this remain to be explored.

Furthermore, considering that giants age at half the rate of humans, if a human were to stay in Elbaf, they might age twice as fast. Mother Carmel, who stayed for 37 years, is noted to be 80 years old, yet her appearance suggests she is much older. This discrepancy raises further questions about the effects of time in Elbaf.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the mystery surrounding Mother Carmel’s long stay in Elbaf and the implications of Louis Arnaud’s warning continue to intrigue fans. While there are many theories, the truth remains elusive. As we await further developments in the story, it is essential to keep an eye on how these elements unfold in the narrative.